BizLawBuz …. The Power of Know

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) enforces most employment related civil rights laws including Title VII, the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and the Age Discrimination and Employment Act (ADEA). Given the ailing economy and increased job cutbacks, the EEOC expects discrimination claims to rise.

On July 15, 2009, the EEOC issued a written guidance intended to help both employers and employees understand what it looks for when deciding whether to challenge the validity of waivers and releases of claims by former employees. The EEOC guidance points out key issues to watch.

First, regardless of the type of discrimination claim, the guidance reminds employers and employees that a waiver will not be enforced if it was not knowingly and voluntarily given. Thus, it is crucial that employees understand that they have the right to refuse to sign the waiver. For this reason, it is equally important that employees be receiving some tangible, additional benefit (typically severance pay) when signing the waiver that is over and above what they would otherwise receive at termination. The release document must make it clear that the release is part of what is being given by the employee in return for severance pay.

Second, because the waiver must be knowing and voluntary, the EEOC will look much more carefully at situations where employees were not encouraged to consult with an attorney. Employers should never engage in “strong-arm” tactics such as insisting that a release be signed immediately.

Third, employers need to understand that – while an employee may be asked to surrender the right to sue and the right to recover damages – a release will not be effective if it tries to prohibit a discharged employee from filing an age discrimination charge with the EEOC. In our practice, we recommend releases that state expressly that the employee retains the right to file an administrative charge but also make clear that the employee cannot expect to profit personally by doing so.

Whether discharging a single employee or administering a group layoff, employers should always look for opportunities to obtain knowing and voluntary waivers of claims by the terminated employees. Given the benefits a valid release provides and the liability risks if the release is not enforceable, employers should always take the time to ensure that each release is tailored to meet the needs of the particular circumstances presented.

Dirk A. Beamer

Last week, the Supreme Court issued a somewhat surprising, employer friendly decision concerning age discrimination. The Court concluded that, to prevail under the federal Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA), a plaintiff must prove that age discrimination was the deciding factor in the employer’s decision making. This makes the ADEA different from Title VII, which governs most other forms of discrimination and which permits a plaintiff to prove only that discrimination was one of the motivating factors. Keep in mind, however, that state laws protecting against age discrimination could be applied differently. More over, experts suggest that the current Congress will act quickly to amend the ADEA in order to counteract the Supreme Court’s decision.

To read the summary of the decision provided by the Society for Human Resource Management, click here.

Dirk A. Beamer